Strong Ties to the Bench and Bar: Chief U.S. District Judge Hosts Tour of Federal Courthouse
March 17, 2015 - Tamara Williams
Chief United States District Judge M. Christina Armijo hosted 14 students and 3 faculty from the Law and Indigenous Peoples Program on a tour of the Pete V. Domenici U.S. Courthouse in downtown Albuquerque on March 3, 2015.
The tour not only demonstrated the chief judge’s graciousness, but it also showed the strong ties the Law School has to the Bench and Bar and the dedicated support the New Mexico legal community extends to law school students.
Tour brings students into daily life of federal court
Professor Barbara Creel and the New Mexico Chapter of the Federal Bar Association collaborated on the tour as a way to bring the students into the daily life of the federal court. Valerie Vigil, law clerk to Judge Judith C. Herrera, coordinated the tour on behalf of the federal court and the chief judge.
“I am grateful to Naomi Barnes and Valerie Vigil and the New Mexico Federal Bar Association for ideas and efforts in making this collaborative event possible,” said Creel.
“We were happy to help coordinate this tour,” says Naomi Barnes, president of the New Mexico Chapter of the Federal Bar Association. “We furthered the mission of our chapter - to provide support to the federal courts and the federal judiciary in New Mexico and to establish a working relationship with the UNM School of Law.”
A visit to two courtrooms
- Chief Judge M. Christina Armijo, (’75) U.S. District Court
- Chief Judge Robert H. Jacobvitz, U.S. Bankruptcy Court
- Judge David T. Thuma, U.S. Bankruptcy Court
- Judge William P. Johnson, U.S. District Court
- Judge Judith C. Herrera, U.S. District Court
- Judge Karen B. Molzen, (’85) Chief U.S. Magistrate Judge
- Judge Kirtan Khalsa, U.S. Magistrate Judge
- Judge Steve C. Yarbrough, (’95) Chief U.S. Magistrate Judge
After Chief Judge Armijo welcomed the students in a reception area, the UNM Law group was invited to observe live proceedings in two courtrooms.
Named after rivers in New Mexico, the courtrooms offer a grand and intimidating setting. The air felt dense and heavy in both courtrooms with the seriousness of the crimes – a bank robbery by a person with a history of drug abuse and a domestic altercation that ended up wounding a police officer – and with the sentencing, how lives were changing. The group listened to a defense attorney’s closing argument, a defendant’s answers to the judge’s questions, and the judges’ sentences in both cases.
Later both judges joined the group in a separate room. Louis Mallette (’17) said it was a great opportunity to see the judges in a more relaxed setting, to talk with them, and to learn how the “judges wrestle with their feelings and personal thoughts while coming to a decision based on the rules.”
Courtroom technology demo
The group was also treated to a demonstration of the courtroom’s state-of-the-art audio-visual equipment by Adam Bustos. They learned the value of preparing beforehand to learn the technology to use it to its best advantage in the courtroom.
Judges share their experiences and expertise
After the technology demo, three judges shared their experiences on the bench. Chief Judge Armijo talked about the statistics of criminal cases in New Mexico, how metro and state courts differ from the federal court, what kinds of cases are heard in federal court. Judge Herrera spoke of her work on the Bench, and Judge Johnson shared his background and expertise in criminal cases.
The students learned that New Mexico federal judges work hard to serve a very large need. “Their dockets are larger than any other border district, and border districts already have a disproportionally large percentage of criminal cases,” said Xochitl Torres Small (’15). “For each hearing, judges read hundreds of pages in briefs and sentencing reports. They carefully consider available resources for rehabilitation, the unique situation of each defendant, and impact on every victim. This is a tough balancing act with such a heavy case load, but they meet the district's needs with compassion and efficiency. ”
Lunch with the judges
Luncheon in the chief judge’s courtroom allowed students to meet with federal attorneys and judges individually and in small groups.
Visiting the Chief Judge’s chambers
The last stop on the tour was a visit to the chief judge’s chambers on the seventh floor. Chief Judge Armijo held a photo taken just minutes after her grandfather, Judge Luis E. Armijo, acquitted Carl C. Magee of manslaughter. Magee was a well-known newspaper man and lawyer who later went on to invent the parking meter.
Federal bench in action
From observing courtroom proceedings to one-on-one meetings with nine members of the federal bench to stories in the chief judge’s chambers, the morning at the Pete V. Domenici Courtroom allowed UNM law students to see the federal bench in action.
“The chief judge was a gracious and welcoming host,” said Creel. “The students were impressed by the human element present in federal court. I am impressed with the time and attention paid to our students. We are so fortunate to have the active participation between the federal bench and the law school. I heard from judges, fellow attorneys and courthouse personnel that all were impressed with the students’ inquisitiveness and interests.”